Why Turkeys on Thanksgiving?

Share this:

The gathering of 52 English colonists and 90 Wampanoag Indians in 1621 marked the beginning of what we call Thanksgiving today. For the Christians who had endured a year of starvation and disease, it was a time to praise God for the abundance of the harvest. For the Wampanoags, it was a time to praise the Earth for the same.

Up until the early 1800s, the annual Thanksgiving ritual was a simple regional holiday celebrated solemnly through fasting and quiet reflection. It wasn’t until a writer named Sarah Josepha Hale began writing romantic, mythical accounts of the First Thanksgiving that things started to shift. In her magazine in 1824, she included recipes for roasted turkeys, bread stuffing, and pumpkin pie – all of the things that today’s holiday meals are likely to contain – and none of the things that would have actually been on the table of the First Thanksgiving.

[Tweet “Up until the early 1800s, Thanksgiving was celebrated solemnly through fasting and quiet reflection.”]

Even as the myths started by Hale began to permeate the culture’s consciousness, “turkey” was still not widely accepted as the quintessential Thanksgiving dish until the mid-20th century when the USDA, at the behest of the National Turkey Federation, bred a bird with white rather than dark flesh. Today, over 270 million turkeys are bred and killed for human consumption, 45 million of which are killed for Thanksgiving.

Hale shaped her traditions out of her ideals, and we should do the same without apology or guilt. That is the ultimate question for all of us: do our actions reflect our values? Do our traditions reflect our beliefs? Do our purchases reflect our ethics? After all, what’s the point in having values if we don’t manifest them in our behavior?

[Tweet “What’s the point in having values if we don’t manifest them in our behavior?”]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

My Vegan Agenda
I’m always struck by the accusation that vegans have an agenda. It’s remarkable to me that our minds have become so jaded by advertising and market…
Irish Soda Bread (Vegan Recipe)
Sometimes you want a delicious loaf of bread last-minute, and you don’t have time to let the dough rise. Or you don’t have live yeast. Or you’ve ne…
Make a One-Time Donation
Many people want to make a one-time contribution to Colleen’s work without receiving anything in return – except knowing that their support makes i…

About Colleen

Hello, and welcome. I’m Colleen, aka The Joyful Vegan, and I’m here to give you the tools and resources you need to eat, cook, travel, and live compassionately and healthfully. 

Donating = Loving

For over twenty years, my work and podcast have remained free (and ad-free) and vibrant thanks to support from listeners, followers, and readers. I have no staff, no interns, and no assistant. What you see (and hear and watch) is a one-woman labor of love that is also my life and my livelihood. If this labor has impacted your life in the past year (or the past decades), please consider aiding its sustenance by becoming a patron or by making a one-time donation. Your support makes all the difference.

Favorite Things

Joyful Vegan Messageware

Wear your compassion on your sleeve (or chest or head!) by choosing any number of my message products.


Includes delicious plant-based recipes and a meal plan!

© 2022 ColleenPatrickGoudreau.com. All Rights Reserved.